Sponsoring an Independent Cuban Library

(for public distribution, copy as needed)

 

 

I was asked to lay out the steps a library board might follow in order to sponsor an independent Cuban library, as the Vermillion, South Dakota, Public Library Board of Trustees did in November, 2004.  The following suggestions may help.

 

1.         As a board, trustees should educate themselves on the issues involved. 

 

This involves first the history and current situation of the independent libraries in Cuba, and second, the debate within the American Library Association on the subject and the ALA’s current position.  Trustees need to discuss sponsorship thoroughly, among themselves and with the library director. 

Unanimity isn’t necessary at the beginning of the discussion, only a willingness to consider sponsorship and what it stands for.  At least one person needs to take the initiative to bring information to the board and keep the discussion alive to the point of a definitive decision.  Preferably this person would be one of the trustees, but it could also be another individual willing to promote the idea with the board.

 

Web sources include www.friendsofcubanlibraries.org  and www.bibliocuba.org. and the ALA’s  http://www.ala.org/ala/iro/iroactivities/alacubanlibraries.htm and Amnesty International’s  http://web.amnesty.org/report2004/cub-summary-eng .

 

Vermillion did this over a period of several monthly board meetings, both in board discussions and by individually studying internet sources between board meetings.

 

2.         Trustees should establish what the goals of the sponsorship are.   

           

The Cuban independent libraries exist in a narrow, fluctuating space between government repression and toleration for the sake of international public relations.  The Cuban government does seem to care what the world thinks and is to some extent susceptible to world opinion.  

Primary goals can be first, to provide one-on-one, personal moral support and solidarity to the brave people running an independent Cuban library; and second, to add to the movement in this country to follow many European cities and library organizations in demanding freedom for jailed Cuban librarians and freedom for all intellectual pursuits in Cuba. 

The expense and difficulty of getting library material from the US to Cuba preclude material support from ever being the main purpose of sponsorship, but at any rate the less tangible goals are the more important ones.

 

3.         The first two web sites mentioned above can be used to help identify a specific Cuban library to sponsor, along with the name of the library director and the library’s shipping address.

 

4.         Objections need to be anticipated before hand, especially in the local community.

Vermillion was the first US library to sponsor a free Cuban one and before we acted we struggled with why that was so.  It seemed like such a simple act of solidarity with beleaguered librarians elsewhere, with no obvious downside, but the lack of a precedent worried some of us.

It’s still not completely clear why there hasn’t been more support from individual libraries such as ours, but some of the reasons must include the ALA’s tepid stance; a concern that it is a very far-flung, and thus inappropriate, issue for a local board to deal with; and also that such an action dilutes the local board’s efforts on behalf of its own library.  Also, until recently there hasn’t really been much effort to promote sponsorship by libraries in the United States.     

In fact there have been no negative implications for us.  None.  All of the press coverage and local feedback has been positive.  Our board president, Jon Flanagin, recently observed that the favorable publicity has enhanced local awareness and appreciation of VPL and has actually strengthened us as an institution in the community.

 We may put together a lobby display about our sister library in Havana, including the eloquent written response from Cuba and  letters of support we have received from people in the US and abroad. We also may add a page to our web site devoted to the sponsorship.

 

If there is someone in the local political or library community that might be opposed, visiting with them before the board acts would be appropriate.  The call would be a courtesy and an opportunity to talk to the individual about the issue.  (But, the whole point of the exercise is to celebrate independent library boards, so no external entity should need to be given veto power either.)  

In Vermillion one of the trustees is also a member of the city council and served as a liaison to that group.  Also, one courtesy call was made to a local professional librarian known to think that libraries should attend to problems closer to home and it turned out that he wasn’t as opposed as had been reported.

 

5.         A funding source should be identified that is completely separate from funds otherwise available to the library for local services; this stipulation should be made clear in the sponsoring resolution.

In Vermillion’s case individual trustees guaranteed any cost above specific contributions received for the purpose.  We have made no effort to solicit financial help, but nonetheless have received several contributions from out of state. 

While material support is part of sponsorship, the gesture of solidarity and moral support is the most important part of sponsorship.  Those goals can be pursued without major expense.

 

6.         A press release should be prepared, along with the sponsoring resolution, and both shared with the local governing body before release to the press. 

There is a ‘reverse pyramid’ theory that recommends putting the most important information in a press release first, due to the likelihood that they may be shortened or truncated in the editing/printing process.  It may not produce the most elegant prose, but may insure that the most important parts of your story are told.

Regarding the distribution list for a press release, some libraries may have the Gale Directory of Publishing and Broadcasting which would help with addresses.

            In Vermillion’s case it took almost two weeks to carefully craft a press release and have it included as a non-discussion item in the city council meeting information packet.  One newspaper pointed out that when they got the release it was old news.  In retrospect the release should have been prepared along with the resolution.

 

7.         Books can be shipped to Cuba via DHL Express.  Label the package contents ‘documents’ to increase the likelihood of delivery.  Spanish language books can be purchased from Amazon, Barnes & Noble and Baker & Taylor.

            No shipment method to Cuba is a sure thing.  Periodic small mailings of books and materials are more prudent than sending a larger amount of material at one time.

            Individual members of groups traveling to Cuba may be able to deliver books to specific libraries. 

Our small shipments of books have each taken five or six days to successfully reach Havana from South Dakota.  Two or three books cost between $40 and $50 to send, depending on weight.  We included copies of our resolution and press release in the first shipment and copies of press clippings in later ones.  The Cuban library director’s response came to us through the help of the first two web sites mentioned above.   To date we haven’t had any experience with travelers carrying books for us; those two web sites would also be able to provide more information about this method of transport. 

 

Vermillion’s sponsoring resolution and the accompanying press release are attached. 

 

I would be happy to correspond or visit with anyone about Vermillion’s experience sponsoring an independent Cuban library.

 

 

Mark Wetmore

605-624-3748

mw@iw.net

 

3-2-05

 

 

A  Resolution

 

Whereas:                   The Vermillion, South Dakota, USA, Public Library Board of Trustees supports the intertwined principles of intellectual freedom and human rights; and

 

Whereas:                   Free access to information is a basic human right; and

 

Whereas:                   Free access to information is the overarching reason libraries exist; and

 

Whereas:                   Free access to uncensored information is the underlying principle that our love of libraries rests upon; and

 

Whereas:                   The Dulce Maria Loynaz Library is a small and poorly-funded library in Havana, Cuba; and

 

Whereas:                   The Dulce Maria Loynaz Library receives no financial or other support from the Cuban government or the City of Havana;

 

 

Therefore be it resolved:

 

                                    That the Vermillion, South Dakota, USA, Public Library Board of Trustees hereby sponsors the Dulce Maria Loynaz Library in Havana, Cuba,

                                    and that this sponsorship will consist of material and moral support for the Dulce Maria Loynaz Library as practicable from Vermillion, such support to be funded solely by private donations for this specific purpose and at no cost to the Vermillion Public Library or the City of Vermillion.

 

 

November 18, 2004

 

 

Press Release                                   December 7, 2004

Vermillion, South Dakota, Library Sponsors a Cuban Library

                            For Immediate Release                     

Contact: Mark Wetmore

605-624-3748;   mw@iw.net  

 

The Vermillion, South Dakota, Public Library Board of Trustees took a stand for intellectual freedom on November 18 when it voted to sponsor the Dulce Maria Loynaz Library in Havana, Cuba.


Cuba’s Dulce Maria Loynaz Library, an unofficial institution free of government control, is one of approximately 250 independent libraries founded since 1998 to challenge restrictions on freedom of information.  The goal of Cuba's independent library movement is to offer public access to uncensored books reflecting all points of view.

 

In March, 2003, many of the independent libraries in Cuba were raided by the State Security police, resulting in lengthy prison terms for more than a dozen librarians.  All of those jailed have been recognized as "prisoners of conscience" by Amnesty International, which is calling for their immediate release. 

 

The Dulce Maria Loynaz Library was one of the institutions singled out during the 2003 crackdown. The director, Gisela Delgado, was not detained during the raid on her library, but her husband, Hector Palacios, was arrested and sentenced to 25 years in prison. During the raid, most of the Loynaz Library's books were confiscated by the police.  The Cuban courts have ordered the burning of many of the books seized from the independent librarians.

"
Cuba’s independent librarians have been targeted for repression because of their principled challenge to censorship,” said Jon Flanagin, president of the Vermillion library trustees.  “We felt we had a moral obligation to offer our support."  Flanagin emphasized that the library trustees’ action will be funded solely by private donations and at no cost to the Vermillion library or to the city.   The first two volumes shipped to Cuba were a collection of Mark Twain and the first of the Harry Potter series, both in Spanish.

 “A hundred years ago the Vermillion library started out with 300 volumes, about the same number of books as the Dulce Maria Loynaz library had before it was raided,” Mark Wetmore, vice president of the trustees, stated.  “But Vermillion’s library grew rapidly from that beginning, in a society that nurtured free access to all types of information.  We hope that our sponsorship of an independent Cuban library will, in some small way, help that process there, as well as encourage other American libraries to offer similar support.”

 

With this action, Vermillion joins the French cities of Paris and Strasbourg, which have also formally adopted a number of Cuba's independent libraries.  The Cuban library is the second with which Vermillion has established a special relationship; in 1989, it adopted the library in its sister city, Ratingen, Germany. 


                                                               ###